From behind prison walls, Sin by Silence reveals the lives of extraordinary women who advocate for a future free from domestic violence.
Inside California’s oldest women’s prisons, Brenda Clubine created the first inmate-initiated and led group in the U.S. prison system to help abused women speak out and realize they are not alone. Over the past two decades, the women of Convicted Women Against Abuse (CWAA) have helped change laws for battered women and raised awareness among those on the outside.
Sin by Silence tells the personal and shocking stories of courageous women, who have learned from their pasts, are changing their futures and, most importantly, can teach us how domestic violence affects us all.
The title of the film comes from the Abraham Lincoln quote, “To sin by silence when we should protest makes cowards of men.” I wanted to break the silence. I wanted this documentary to spark vital conversations to begin protesting the incarceration of battered women and the silent crisis of domestic violence. I wanted the film to help create environments for victims of abuse to feel comfortable to finally ask for help. I wanted the film to ignite a passion in individuals to finally speak up and say to that friend they are worried about, “Is everything alright? I’m really worried about you.” Just saying such a simple phrase could eventually be the difference between life and death of someone.” – Olivia Klaus, Director & Producer
Even before finishing the film and crafting the campaign strategy, the team developed one crucial objective – inspire audiences to Do Something! With this mission, the objectives became clear:
The team knew that the powerful stories of the women who had experienced horrific violence would move people. These women, the true experts on domestic violence, are everyday women. This became the campaign’s key element and focus—this could happen to you! When watching the film, audience members could put themselves in the shoes of women with whom they would never normally relate – women in prison for 15 years to life.
Sin by Silence premiered at the Cleveland International Film Festival in March 2009. The following fall, they launched the Stop the Violence community tour to take the film directly into communities that needed to hear the message and could create change. In planning the Stop the Violence initiatives, the team identified those states with the worst domestic violence statistics. Utilizing the National Coalition Against Domestic Violence statistic reports, the team reviewed statistics and formulated a plan that targeted Arizona, California, Indiana, Kansas, Louisiana, Missouri, New Mexico, Ohio, Texas, and Washington.
The team connected with each state’s domestic violence coalition to identify where a screening might best be utilized within their network and to develop a plan of action. They then connected with various organizations, non-profits, universities and churches that would benefit from a screening of the film and discussion. To maximize the effectiveness and reach of the film, they scheduled the tour to coincide with Domestic Violence Awareness Month in October 2009, allowing them to on expand upon the outreach efforts already in place through community partners.
The Stop the Violence tour traveled throughout 10 states, had 40 screenings, and connected with over 5400 screening attendees. A safe places was created for audience members to share their own personal stories of tragedy. Organizations connected with new advocates who were ready to join the cause and begin working together. Based on audience reaction as well as statistics, Sin by Silence team also focused on reaching youth, using the stories of the CWAA women, who met their abusive partners in their teenage years. The Stop the Violence tour included 10 events on college campuses, which had higher participation than regular community screenings. Based on this fact, they launched a campus initiative.
The Sin by Silence team also created teaching videos designed to spark further discussion. By creating more than two hours of additional video content, they were able to include interviews with experts on abusive relationships, law enforcement leaders and leaders in faith-based communities about domestic violence, incarceration and more. In 2009, Women Make Movies released this educational DVD; it still remains a top seller. The team also created digital versions of their resources to help educators and advocates, creating kits that were accessible through the website. This allowed the campaign to continue and facilitated the film’s continued use.
In addition, almost two years after its festival premiere, the film secured a broadcast on Discovery Networks reaching 2.2 million viewers, providing yet another platform for the film.
In addition to the 40 tour events, 427 host-a-screening kits were ordered and there were 258 events hosted on university campuses. Many of these screenings led to unique conversations and actions that are difficult to document. Here are some the more tangible things we do know happened after screenings:
In addition to this increased involvement by individuals, college students and local organizations, there has also been movement on the policy front. Most notably in California, where there are two bills – The Sin by Silence Bills (AB 593 & AB 1593) – that were championed by Assemblywoman Fiona Ma (D-San Francisco and San Mateo Counties). As she states:
“After watching the moving film Sin by Silence, I decided that action needed to be taken. I’m committed to helping incarcerated victims of domestic violence seek justice. These bills will ensure survivors behind bars can have a second chance to tell their stories and be judged fairly with all the facts in place.”
These bills will help the incarcerated, battered women that have been trapped for decades behind prison walls. AB 593 clarifies the current legislation to include the domestic violence victims that were unintentionally denied their original writ of habeas corpus due to limited expert testimony evidence. AB 1593 provides victims of domestic violence who have suffered Intimate partner battering a chance to present their evidence in an effective way during the parole process. With California being the only state to currently have legislation in place that specifically allows incarcerated survivors to petition the court and be resentenced, The Sin by Silence Bills set the precedence for other states to follow suit. California’s Governor Brown signed the bills into law in September 2012.
Sin by Silence offers many lessons for those of us who are focused on using stories as a vehicle to engage audiences around difficult issues. Perhaps most importantly is the power of face-to-face events with the right audience. This project had a strong festival run, but did not necessarily receive the “buzz” and hype that some documentaries receive and was not picked up immediately for broadcast or broader distribution. Nevertheless, the team was focused and passionate about their goals and worked to get the film to the right audiences through their Stop the Violence Tour. They were also highly strategic in how this tour was structured, working with partners and advocates to determine the call to action, the timing and the target groups.
This campaign also demonstrates the need for flexibility and understanding your audiences and the issue. This team tracked who was attending their screenings and what the reactions were. They also understood the risk factors and research around domestic violence and its prevention. Based on this, they understood that there was a huge opportunity to reach college women with the message of prevention and that this segment would be eager to get involved.
Another lesson from Sin By Silence is that the life of a documentary film audience engagement campaign can live on as long as the team has the resources, motivation and support to push it forward. Director, Olivia Klaus, has been a tireless advocate for the film, the women in the film and the issue. With her dedication and the groundwork that has already been laid, we are confident that this film will continue to inspire change for years to come.
This project has had great impact on individuals, communities and organizations and ultimately has led to concrete changes in policy in California, which can serve as a model for other states. This was possible in large part because the team was focused on their end goals and continually looked for opportunities to move their objectives forward.